Questions from the Scripture text: What are they to set apart (19:1–3a)? For what purpose (v3b–7)? What might they have to do in the future (v8–9)? Why do all of this (v10)? What case does this not cover (v11–12)? What does properly executing murderers accomplish (v13)? What is one way to prevent murder (v14, cf. Jam 4:2; 1Ki 21)? How must prosecution proceed (v15–17)? What must be done to false witnesses (v18–20)? What does proper justice demand from the court (21)? What killing is permissible, and Who will fight for them (20:1–4)? What may/should they do about waging war, since it is God Who fights for them (v5–9)? What procedure are they to follow, when the city or nation is very far from them (v10–15)? And what procedure are they to follow with the peoples and cities of the land (v16–18)? What are they to be especially careful about when laying siege to a city (v19–20)? What situation may occur in the land (21:1)? What procedure are they to follow in such a case (v2–8)? With what effect (v9)? For whom do v9–14 make special provision? What protections/ considerations are given to them (v14)? How important was inheritance, and what sort of son was to be treated as a capital offender (v15–21)? What might be done with the body of an executed man, as a warning to others (v22)? But what guidelines limited this (v23)? How were they to love their neighbor as themselves (22:1–4)? What failures to maintain holiness would make them an offense to God and endanger their lives (v5–11)? What were they to do to remind themselves to maintain holiness (v12, cf. Num 15:37–41)?
How must Israel apply the sixth commandment to their life in the land? Deuteronomy 19:1–22:12 looks forward to the hearing of God’s Word, publicly read, in the holy assembly on the coming Lord’s Day. In these seventy-six verses of Holy Scripture, the Holy Spirit teaches us that Israel were to honor God’s holiness by treating His image in man as sacred.
This is the second longest section of the sections in Deuteronomy, applying each of the Ten Commandments to Israel’s national life in the land. The longest was the First Commandment, beginning of the first table of the law. This is also the most difficult section to understand how all of the different parts fit in with the particular commandment that is being covered. The obviousness with which the rest of the commandments are being covered in their respective sections makes us to say not that our system of understanding must be mistaken, but that we need help to understand how all of the different parts fit with the sixth commandment. With God helping us, we will do our best.
The first part of understanding the Sixth Commandment is to understand that not all killing is murder. There is manslaughter (ch19) and just war (ch20). In the case of manslaughter, there's a duty not to shed the innocent blood of the manslayer (v10). So, there's the system with the avenger of blood and the cities of refuge. These are to be evenly spaced. And if God expands their land, they're even to add more cities. And even the necessity of a good road system was especially so that the manslayer would have good access to the nearest city of refuge (v3).
The Lord values life to the extent that He particularly values the life of the manslayer. The law in v14 about moving landmarks is restated here for the prevention of the murders to which this might lead (cf. Jam 4:2). And this relevance is actually proved out, sadly, later in the life of Israel, with Naboth and his vineyard, and Ahab's desire for it, and Jezebel's solution: just eliminate Naboth (cf. 1Ki 21). So, here, the Lord reinforces the sacredness of property boundaries, even though we're not in the midst of the eighth commandment, because the breaking of other commandments often leads to murder. The assault on the image of God is the ultimate outcome of the neglect of the law of God. And of course, Jezebel, you remember, didn't just violate verse 14. She did it thinking that she was really doing everything on the up and up because she satisfied verse 15 and following that two or three witnesses was necessary. However, the witnesses that she produced were false witnesses and there was to be a method of appeal.
The priests have been established as a higher court (cf. 17:8–13). With so much at stake in capital cases, v15–21 establish that, if a witness was discovered to be false, he would receive the penalty that the accused would have received. So, God emphasizes the necessity of exact justice. v21 is not a code of vengeance among a primitive culture. “Life-for-life, eye-for-eye, tooth-for-tooth, hand-for-hand, foot-for-foot” is describing exact and equitable justice: that the penalty would always fit the crime.
Manslaughter is one killing that isn't murder. Another is just (righteous) war. Ch 20 functions in two ways. First, it is a reminder that in just war the killing is not necessarily murder. Second, it reminds us how much the Lord Himself values and defends the lives of His people. Thus, they don't have to make war in the way that others do. They don't have to desperately muster every last person. The Lord is the One to Whom the victory belongs (v3–4). Their life is precious in His sight. Therefore, they can do things like make sure that those who have new land (v5–6), or who are newly married (v7), or even who are fearful (v8), do not go out to battle with the rest of the people. They're also not to go literally “scorched earth” in order to win a victory, sacrificing the usefulness of the land (v19–20). God was not just giving them victory. He was preserving their life. The point was to make them into a people whose God is YHWH, Who is not like the gods of the other nations. For them, this made a difference between those who were in the land, who had to be completely eliminated (v16–18), and then those where they were enlarging their borders, who would be invited to become part of the people of God (v10–15) as servants and forced laborers—but also as worshipers of YHWH, bringing them under His as the covenant people of Israel. However, if they were not willing to live in this way, then they were to be warred against, and the Lord would deliver them into their hand.
The guilt of bloodshed is so significant that there is not only individual responsibility, but also corporate responsibility. So, if there was a murder, but they couldn't solve it (21:1), then they had to go out to a primitive place where there's flowing water and yet land that has not been tilled, indicating perhaps cleansing by the flowing of the water, but going to basically a place where the only one who can see is YHWH, just as when the murder was committed (v2–4). and They execute this heifer in such a way as to show that it is not a sacrifice. The heifer, like the washing of the hands, is an object lesson: that a dreadful execution has occurred. It is a heifer that has never been used yet for anything, so the loss is great, just as the loss of every human life is great. And then there is the washing of hands (v6). The participation of the priests, the highest court in the land (v5), reminds us that there's a corporate responsibility for murder and for dealing rightly with murder.
Finally, there are a number of laws that are more difficult to understand under the umbrella of the sixth commandment. One of the sad outcomes of war is that there would be so many widows made by the war, so there is a regard for their life that provision was made for the, that they could be brought into Israel as a wife, and that if this happened, then they could not be returned to the status of a slave or a property (v10–14). v15–21 cover another capital crime: the uncorrectable son. So much rests upon sons for the multi-generational well-being of the people of God, and so important is the Fifth Commandment issue of properly submitting to and honoring and obeying authority, that even though inheritance is so important, a son who would not obey the voice of his father or mother, even when chastened, was to be executed. That was ultimately a capital crime, which likely connects it here as well, with other executions that were also to be warnings: the hangings in v22–23 do not describe a method of execution. The execution has already occurred halfway through v 22. The hanging is a display of the body of the guilty as a warning to the living that they not commit the same sort of capital crime. This was done in many cultures, has continued to be done in many cultures, but in Israel this was regulated because of the holiness of the land and the holiness of the people unto the Lord. The displayed body had to be taken down and buried that same day, because the hanged one the one, who is under capital crime and executed by the people as a capital criminal, was also under the curse of God. The display of his body might be a warning to people, but the first thing that you think about is not what people see, but what God sees. And the land would be defiled by leaving this accursed man as a display.
Then, in 22:1–12, we have some rounding out that helps us remember the principles behind the Sixth Commandment. At heart, it's a requirement that one love his neighbor as himself, as borne out by v1–4. In Israel, dealing properly with murder was required not only for maintaining societal order, but especially for the honoring of God’s holiness. The ways of the peoples of the land were an abomination to YHWH: confusing men with women (v5), abuse of creation (v6–7), carelessness of human life (v8), and mixtures that resisted statutes that the Lord instituted to maintain Israel’s holy distinctiveness (v9–11). Israel were to be holy unto YHWH, in the keeping of His commandments, as continuously indicated to them by the tassels on their clothing (v12, cf. Num 15:37–41).
When we, who are holy, do not have regard for the separation between us and the world, that God has put upon us, we do disregard our own life. Living worldly, when God has called us holy, is a form of suicide (cf. end of v7). May the Lord gave you to have regard for your own life, and others' lives, as His word teaches us. Most of all, may He give us to hope in the Lord Jesus Christ, for there is a second death, the everlasting death. And praise God; for, His regard for our life has been such that He added to Himself a human life, and He gave His human life for us. He is the great regarder of His image in man, and we should follow Him in that, rejoicing that He has done that for us
Whom do you most need to grow in loving as yourself? How are you in danger of disregarding your call to be distinct from the world? In what way are you most having regard for the life (and eternal life!) of others?
Sample prayer: Father, forgive us, for we have not valued life so seriously as You have, because we have not valued You so seriously as we ought. So, forgive our sins for the sake of Christ, and conform us to His image. Make us to love one another as ourselves, and to often be thinking about whether or not we are giving offense to you. Grant these things, we ask, in Jesus's name. Amen.
Suggested songs: ARP15 “Within Your Tent, Who Will Reside” or TPH174 “The Ten Commandments”